Back to Insights

Strategy & transformation

Good to Ordinary

When Benchmarking Weakens What Makes a Company Distinctive

First published on LinkedIn.

Good to Great beside the conceptual Good to Ordinary book
Good to Great alongside an imagined Good to Ordinary cover: an illustration of the transformation risk.

Studying what successful companies have in common does not tell us everything about why customers choose each of them.

In Good to Great, Jim Collins follows an approach familiar in studies of business success: comparing companies that met his research criteria for a transition to greatness with companies that did not, seeking patterns that distinguish the groups. That search offers a useful starting point for learning.

My concern begins when we turn shared patterns into a template for transformation, without understanding the distinctive strengths of the organization we are changing.

The risk is a journey from good to ordinary: a company adopts more accepted, standardized, or globally recognized practices while weakening the capabilities that made it worth choosing.

Common principles leave room for distinctive strengths

The label “successful” always deserves care. Successful by which measures, over what period, in which context, and for whom? A company's classification within a study should be read within those boundaries.

Shared characteristics also leave questions unanswered. How did each company create value in its particular market? Which relationships, expertise, decisions, or combinations of activities supported its position?

A common principle can take different forms. Two businesses may both value responsiveness while organizing and managing authority, information, and customer contact differently.

Collins himself leaves room for this distinction. His Hedgehog Concept asks companies to understand what they can be best at, alongside their passion and economic engine. He also warns that professional management can suppress entrepreneurial energy when it becomes bureaucracy.

The warning therefore concerns how success research is applied, rather than the research itself. Similarities can inform better questions and reveal opportunities for improvement. Each organization's sources of value still require focused, independent investigation.

When learning becomes conformity

Benchmarking becomes risky when the organization we choose as a model supplies the answer before we have understood our own problem.

Consider a hypothetical distributor known for resolving delivery problems quickly. Salespeople understand customers and have enough discretion to arrange practical solutions.

A review reveals inconsistent decisions and weak documentation. Management adopts an approval process used by a respected competitor.

Records improve, but customers now wait while requests move between departments. The company has addressed a control weakness while weakening responsiveness.

What may have been overlooked is that the competitor's process could suit its customer promise, staffing, technology, or commercial exposure. Its suitability for our hypothetical distributor remains a separate question.

This is how conformity can enter transformation or benchmarking projects: resemblance becomes a sign of progress before the consequences for customer value have been tested.

Align three design disciplines around your strategy

Protecting a distinctive capability requires understanding how the organization delivers it. Organization architecture, service design, and process design offer overlapping perspectives:

  • Organization architecture: the roles, authority, skills, resources, and incentives supporting the required capabilities.
  • Service design: the customer and employee experience, and the interactions and operations that make it possible.
  • Process design: the movement of work, information, decisions, and controls across the business.

All three should align with the organization's value-creation strategies, strategic capabilities, and human-centered values.

Galbraith's Star Model connects strategy with organizational design choices and emphasizes their alignment. Service blueprints expose relationships between customer interactions, people, and supporting processes. Strategic process design makes that alignment concrete in how work gets done.

In the distributor example, the strategic promise is rapid resolution. Service design must make that response possible for customers and employees. Process design must provide suitable decision paths. Organization architecture must provide the authority, information, and skills to use them.

A change to one area needs to be assessed through the others. An efficient approval step may still make the overall promise harder to fulfill.

Preserve the capability and improve its foundations

Similarity or difference alone does not establish that a practice is valuable.

The relevant questions concern customer value, contribution to business results, and what would be lost if a practice disappeared. Customer feedback, operating data, and actual decisions can help test the answers.

In the same example, preserving responsiveness need not mean preserving every existing procedure. If speed depends on one manager's constant intervention, the capability has fragile foundations. Clear decision limits, better information, and wider team competence may support it more reliably.

To assess process performance, service performance, and organizational capabilities together, we could examine handling time, errors, resolution cost, customer effort, and the team's ability to respond consistently without a particular individual.

The purpose is to establish whether the proposed change strengthens the business's ability to deliver its strategy while addressing the identified weakness.

Learning from others and developing our own advantages can support the same transformation. The discipline lies in understanding what to adopt, how to adapt it, and which valuable capabilities require deliberate protection.

Before approving your next benchmarking or transformation project, trace one distinctive capability from the customer promise through its processes, people, and decision rights, and test how the proposed changes affect it.

References

Jim Collins. Good to Great. Author's book overview, “The Hedgehog Concept”, and “A Culture of Discipline.”

Jay R. Galbraith. “Star Model.” Galbraith Management Consultants.

Sarah Gibbons. “Service Blueprints: Definition.” Nielsen Norman Group.